Kill Tony #284 — Andy Kindler
Guests: Andy Kindler
Lineup
Set: Zachary opened with weight loss material, making absurdist comparisons about losing 160 pounds and his history of being extremely overweight. He used fractions, Tic Tacs, and an elevator anecdote.
Interview: Revealed this was his second year doing stand-up, only his fifth or sixth time on stage. He discussed losing weight from 2016 onward, starting at 375 pounds, inspired by podcasts like Joe Rogan's. He has Asperger's syndrome and wears a patriotic fanny pack.
- Lost weight equivalent to a whole human being; if fractions of a ton measure weight, he had a problem
- Worked with two fat coworkers; together weighed more than half a ton and got stuck in elevator
- Lost weight by stopping 60-can-per-day Coke habit and walking around
- Zachary revealed he has Asperger's syndrome during interview, which Tony awkwardly pivoted by mentioning Hans Asperger was a Nazi
- Tony made a Star Trek vs Star Wars joke connecting to Zachary's appearance and the weight loss journey
- Revealed he tried three times to get on Kill Tony, finally succeeded on road show after two LA attempts
Set: Kyle did edgy material about hashtags and social media mishaps, starting with the #foodporn vs #childporn joke. He also made a joke about a mixed message from sitting with his grandmother about sexual harassment.
Interview: Kyle has been doing stand-up for two and a half years, runs shows an hour and a half south of Fort Wayne. He works for a mortgage company processing documents, used to be a bank teller, and plays in a bluegrass/country band.
- Posted niece's birthday party pictures with #childporn hashtag; now can't use internet
- Grandmother's quote about stopping sexual harassment in Hollywood mixed with pound sign joke
- Jeremiah made a 'blue cheese band' joke implying Kyle's appearance, which Kyle laughed off
- Kyle revealed he's straightedge and doesn't get invited to parties; Jeremiah made aggressive angel/devil appearance jokes
Set: Steve performed material about the Women's March, criticizing the homogeneity of the pink pussy hat design and making absurdist vagina comparisons. He suggested vaginas are more diverse than represented.
Interview: Been doing stand-up for almost two years. Originally from Garrett, Indiana. Recently discovered he's part Cherokee, Irish, and Black through a family reunion where his estranged father met his grandfather. Works with Amish people building pop-up campers.
- Not all vaginas look the same as the pink pussy hats; referenced bulldog, gum, sideways, number 3 vaginas
- Vaginas have different looks like various Arby's menu items, setting unattainable beauty standards
- Revealed complex racial heritage discovery at family reunion where estranged father met his own father after 50 years
- Discussion about working with Amish people and their lack of deodorant, leading to offensive characterizations
- Joel made 'African-American Smith' joke after Steve discussed blacksmith work in Amish context
Set: Nathan started strong with an Ohio vs Indiana joke but was immediately heckled. He recovered and did material about balding, bowling alleys, and a story about receiving a text of someone's small penis at age 14.
Interview: 25 years old from Dayton, Ohio. Works the meat and seafood counter at a grocery store for three years. This was his first time on stage doing stand-up. He's shy and nervous but loves comedy.
- Wear hats because balding and embarrassed; goes to bowling alleys to look at kids' names in mirrors
- Received text of small penis at age 14, confused why someone would keep a dick pic in contacts
- Crowd heckled Nathan immediately upon mentioning Ohio, causing him to stumble at the start
- Tony defended Nathan against hecklers, saying Ohio matters and created airplanes, referencing Kent State
- Andy Kindler broke character laughing at Nathan's riffs, creating a memorable moment
Set: Andy opened with his surname 'Koons' and made material about how Black people won't be his friends because of it. He discussed how friendships never last past exchanging full names due to the unfortunate phonetic similarity to a racial slur.
Interview: Started stand-up seriously in April. Inspired by Kill Tony podcast. From Michigan originally, Kansas/Oklahoma area. Married with three kids, works delivering medical equipment like oxygen and hospital beds.
- Last name Koons prevents Black friendships; they won't say 'hang out with Koons' in same sentence
- Tried to use Flintstone as a stage name instead; explained the surname problem directly to audience
- Andy acknowledged the awkwardness directly and made it his opening bit, showing vulnerability and self-awareness
- Revealed personal sacrifice: works crazy long hours delivering medical equipment for minimal stand-up time with family
- Discussion about bedroom dynamics with wife and toddler sleeping in bed, leading to uncomfortable jokes
Set: Anthony performed about student loan forgiveness scams, exposing how offers claiming loan forgiveness actually require repayment. He discussed the illusion of forgiveness and worked through the math.
Interview: Been doing stand-up about four years. Originally from Mooresville, Indiana south of Indianapolis. Mother is a safety director for construction; father struggles with alcoholism. Has two younger brothers. Works in Fort Wayne doing comedy.
- Student loan forgiveness program requires 240 repayment installments; not forgiveness but actually repayment
- Revealed that the comedy bar where he performed burnt down two days after the open mic
- Previously appeared on Kill Tony in Columbus years ago, making dirt; became a callback reference
- Discussed making topsoil commercially and the difficulty of Fort Wayne's limited comedy scene
Set: Cory's first time on stage involved a long, punchline-free story about masturbating to a classmate's yearbook photo in the shower and his brother telling that girl about it at a school dance, destroying his confidence.
Interview: 27 years old, first-time stand-up performer. Does special fabrication and welding, building machinery for cutting jerky and meat smokers. From Kansas City, drove to Fort Wayne. Has a girlfriend, enjoys hiking and kayaking.
- Jerked off to yearbook photo in shower; forgot picture; brother told girl at school dance
- First-time comic committed entirely to a story with no punchlines, despite being coached to add them
- Joel made werewolf joke about Cory's hairy appearance, comparing him to Daniel Bryan
- Tony encouraged him not to commit entirely to punchline-less stories and suggested other material
Set: Joe performed observational material about Family Feud format variations (white families vs minorities) and made commentary about TV. He opened with a joke about donating cars for breast cancer being a bad trade.
Interview: Seven years of stand-up, started in Houston, moved to San Jose, now Indianapolis. Was a civil engineer working on BART light rail, got laid off. Moves around frequently due to father's work. Big wrestling fan with a podcast, plays Dungeons & Dragons.
- Family Feud format: white family versus increasingly absurd opponents (other races, science)
- Donate car for breast cancer is bad trade; car is worth more than medical condition
- Joe revealed worked on BART light rail system; Tony made obvious joke about running trains on the city
- Discussed running comedy podcast about professional wrestling with 100 episodes and Joe Rogan guest appearance
Set: Brett performed self-aware material about being compared to an autistic comedian, eye contact avoidance and introversion. He discussed anxiety advice from comics (drink/smoke), being straightedge, and Monster energy drink ingredients being Linkin Park lyrics.
Interview: Five years of stand-up. Lives 40 minutes north of Detroit in Trump country. Previously hung out with Tony and prevented him from falling off a high stool; they bonded over Post Malone joke. Has a baby. Wrestling fan since childhood.
- Compared to autistic comedian but no details; eye contact avoidance is how to find love
- Straightedge means no drinking/smoking and no party invites; Monster energy ingredients are Linkin Park lyrics
- Friends' anxiety advice is just 'drink' or 'smoke'; straightedge alternative leaves him isolated
- Tony and Brett bonded over previous encounter where Brett prevented Tony from falling, then made Post Malone joke
- Tony coached Brett on opening up about other topics beyond autism diagnosis material
Kyle Forsyth
Set: Kyle performed material about his new beer delivery driver job and looking like someone who works for a beer company. He made an awkward first date hiking joke where he jokes about murdering his girlfriend.
Interview: Five years of stand-up by December. From Metro Detroit. Met girlfriend on Tinder using a friend's one-liner about campfire stories. In Dungeons & Dragons for two years. Girlfriend dislikes his death material jokes.
- Works for beer company as delivery driver; already looks like he works for beer company
- First date girlfriend suggested hiking; joked it was perfect way to murder her; girlfriend dislikes the bit
- Tony made Bray Wyatt comparison due to Kyle's facial hair and beard style
- Discussed Tinder profile one-liner from friend Brett about campfire stories that successfully attracted girlfriend
Set: Brian spent his entire 60 seconds roasting Tony with surface-level jokes about appearance, sexuality, priests, and Netflix special. He made comparisons to Tom Cruise, Jerry Sandusky, and gay material.
Interview: First-time comedian. From four hours south of Fort Wayne, will be in Nashville. Works at Ford. Has a son who travels with him to shows and may be funnier. Interested in material about Black people and race.
- Tony is to stand-up what Caitlyn Jenner is to stand-up (gender transition comparison)
- Tony looks like gay daywalker from Blade; got Netflix special called One Shot because that's what boyfriend left
- Tony looks like Tom Cruise stranded on cruise; looks like LA Raiders coach taking Jerry Sandusky advice
- First-time comedian chose to spend entire set roasting host instead of doing original material
- Tony acknowledged the balls it took but suggested Brian might have spots his son could fill better
- Brian mentioned son travels with him catching all shows nationwide; son reportedly funnier