KILL TONY Wiki

Kill Tony #392

📅 September 22, 2019 📍 La Jolla, CA Comedy Store 🎤 9 comedians ⭐ 1 regular

Open on YouTube ↗

Lineup

1

Geoff

Set: Jeff joked about his unusual name spelling, bullying in middle school, developing feminine traits like talking with hands, owning many swimsuits, and a confusing closer about shoving objects up his butt.

Interview: Tony relentlessly questioned Jeff's contradictory closer about anal objects despite claiming not to be gay. Discussion covered his volleyball hobby, fiancée, and hospital data analytics job.

Bits:
  • Name spelled GE o FF causes T-Mobile confusion and school nicknames like 'gay off'
  • Developed feminine traits by hanging with girls in middle school (hand talking, swimsuits)
  • Confusing closer: 'I like to put phallic objects in my butt, I'm not gay'
Moments:
  • Tony repeatedly attacks the closer for making no sense logically
  • Fiancée present in audience; Tony makes joke about marrying a gay man
2

Nathan Driver

Set: Nathan joked about his mom's funeral coinciding with her stopping his phone bill, going through a breakup and working on his 'revenge personality' instead of revenge body, and made a confusing closer about his cat thinking he's gay.

Interview: Tony interrogated Nathan's contradictory jokes and weak closer. Discussion revealed Nathan works in medical device R&D, had successful separated parents (dad watches Alex Jones, mom lives with a woman), and Tony called his mom live on air asking if she's a lesbian.

Bits:
  • Mom stopped paying phone bill after dying; funeral Friday needs $60
  • Working on revenge personality instead of revenge body after breakup
  • Confusing closer: cat thinks he's gay and it's annoying
Moments:
  • Tony calls Nathan's mom live during interview to ask if she's gay
  • Nathan mentions another Nathan was previously on show; Tony finds Nathan's friend in audience
3

Pablo Pantaleon

Set: Pablo joked about having a baby in Mexico he'll never find, meeting his dad and their beard comparison, claiming he has his mom's big nipples, and a transitional joke about becoming Filipino.

Interview: Pablo revealed he works as pool boy at the Comedy Store, has never been on the show, does stand-up four years, fights/does jiu-jitsu for fun, and never knew his father (met him at 13, ate breakfast together).

Bits:
  • Just had baby in Mexico with mom; they'll never find him; God is good
  • Dad has nice beard but Pablo only has 'qin dynasty thing'; inherited mom's big nipples
  • Wears Hawaiian shirts to hide his big lady nipples; transitioning to Filipino
Moments:
  • Tony challenges Pablo to show his nipples; he demonstrates they're long and can tie balloons
  • Pablo reveals he never knew his father, met him once at 13
  • Strong performance with memorable physical comedy; Tony offers to teach him catch
4

Shaun Baker

Set: Shaun joked about his 11-year-old son's confidence about future sex, his brother's wedding where family pressured for grandkids, and his dark closer about getting an abortion from shooting loads.

Interview: Shaun is a wedding photographer from New York living in San Diego for 6 years due to wife's mold poisoning. He witnessed a bride leave before ceremony but still got paid. Discussed watching fail videos and seemingly creepy interest in girls.

Bits:
  • 11-year-old son confidently says he WILL have sex with pretty volleyball girls someday
  • Brother's wedding: family wants grandkids, brother says 'we're trying,' Shaun interprets as creampie
  • Dark closer: 'I shot a load in somebody once, I didn't get any ons, I got an abortion'
Moments:
  • Witnessed bride leave before ceremony but still charged and captured photos
  • Tony compares him to Tim Curry from It, references his creepy smile
5

William Montgomery

Regular

Set: William performed a rambling set claiming to be from La Jolla, discussing zantac 75 acid reflux, working at a wood fire pizza place, past illnesses (strep throat, Legionnaires disease), and various incoherent stories.

Interview: William is a notorious Kill Tony regular known for constant lying. Discussed fabricated stories about working on Zorro TV show, taking amoxicillin, opening a weed operation in Arkansas, and made increasingly absurd claims that Tony called out as lies.

Bits:
  • Claims been on zantac 75 for acid reflux; from La Jolla; worked at wood-fired pizza
  • Claims worked for Zorro production for three years as Antonio Banderas's cousin
  • Multiple disease claims: strep throat, Legionnaires, hammer toe, whooping cough, Lyme's disease
Moments:
  • William enters on the back of another person's electric wheelchair - unprecedented entrance
  • Tony becomes genuinely angry at William's fabrications and contradictions
  • Claims to have spilled Sprite in bathroom but it was clearly 7-Up; Tony calls him out
6

Andrew Matney

Set: Andrew joked about watching porn with his wife, the awkwardness of choosing content together, and struggling with stamina, ending with a 6-minute prediction if he only watched porn.

Interview: Andrew is a 38-year-old corporate attorney married 5 years with twin 10-year-old daughters. Discussed his Lebanese/Russian/Polish heritage, being short (5'2), designing games for Black Ops zombies, furnishing his apartment, and his tall girlfriend (6'1).

Bits:
  • Wife wanted to watch porn together; has to pretend he doesn't know every menu
  • Can't pick 45-minute porn videos; would only last 6 minutes if watching
  • Girlfriend 6'1', he's 5'9'; awkward to be spontaneous; uses step stool in kitchen
Moments:
  • Tony compares Andrew to Danny DeVito, jokes about being short and needing step stool
  • Joel asks Andrew to demonstrate oral sex with microphone; Andrew complies awkwardly
  • Tony makes reference to Andrew's daughters and pedophilia implications during interview

Set: Marcos joked about being Puerto Rican but not looking it, his father vacuuming with a Ghostbusters backpack, and discussed living in Oceanside and painting parking lots.

Interview: Marcos paints parking stripes and sponsors fighters at a boxing gym. Claims to punch people for a living and support fighters. Has 8 children (4 boys, 4 girls), wife dislikes his Chuck E Cheese wardrobe. Bragged he can 'get any woman pregnant.'

Bits:
  • Puerto Rican but doesn't look it; somewhere between Ricky Martin and Adam Sandler
  • Dad used Ghostbusters backpack vacuum to clean entire floor with dust buster
Moments:
  • Marcos claims to punch people for living; Tony calls him out for exaggerating
  • Brags 'I can get any woman in this room pregnant'; Tony notes bizarre brag
  • Tony criticizes his fashion sense; wife told him not to wear shirt
8

Craig Sutton

Set: Craig joked about having a girlfriend taller than him (6'1' vs his 5'9'), awkward sexual positioning requiring a step stool, and her calling him gay right before he orgasms.

Interview: Craig is a 33-year-old game designer working on Black Ops zombies mode, recently started living alone 3 years ago, has 10-month girlfriend. Admitted to calling a kid the N-word in Left for Dead video game, apologized profusely.

Bits:
  • Girlfriend 6'1' is his 'better 2/3' not 'better half' due to height difference
  • Made out at kitchen counter, bent her over, quietly placed down step stool to climb
  • Girlfriend calls him gay right before he orgasms; finally has friend who does
Moments:
  • Craig admits to calling kid N-word in Left for Dead video game; apologized
  • Described feeling 'swell vil power' saying the slur before immediately regretting it
9

Xan Bernay

Set: Xan joked about childhood worries (tetanus, scoliosis, amnesia, wrongful conviction) that proved irrelevant to adult life, noting her white privilege makes wrongful conviction unlikely.

Interview: Xan is a lawyer and partner at law firm, sixth time performing stand-up. Travels to Japan frequently, uncle is JFK conspiracy theorist running Book Depository tour, no current romantic life, interested in discussing her dating and sexual preferences.

Bits:
  • Worried about tetanus, scoliosis, amnesia as child; none actually happened
  • Worried about wrongful conviction as child until realized she's white
  • Schools tested kids for scoliosis; some marked for secondary screening and never talked to again
Moments:
  • Tony praises Xan's natural stage presence for sixth performance; compares her appearance to Roseanne
  • Joel makes joke about her going to Japan repeatedly, implying fetish/latex interest
  • Uncle runs JFK conspiracy tour at Book Depository; has Zapruder film copy and yarn wall theory