Kill Tony #190 — Doug Benson, Big Jay Oakerson, Dom Irrera
Guests: Doug Benson · Big Jay Oakerson · Dom Irrera
Lineup
Set: Jeff opens with observational jokes about his appearance and a texting mishap where he autocorrected 'Heroes' to 'Herpes,' leading to an unexpected date. The set meanders through various topics with minimal punchlines.
Interview: Tony and the panel critique Jeff's set structure, noting he sets up jokes without payoffs. They discuss his background in sales, his four years doing comedy, and his struggles as a newer performer.
- Autocorrects 'Heroes' to 'Herpes' in text to girl, she shows up anyway
- Looks like 80-year-old 20-year-old, doesn't understand age
- Panel collectively tells Jeff to listen back to his own sets and recognize the structural issues
- Jeremiah Watkins intervenes to defend Jeff and discourage the panel from being overly harsh
Set: Alex performs about dating and high-drama relationships, mentioning wearing a Phantom of the Opera mask during oral sex on his Tinder profile. The set is extremely brief, approximately 35 seconds.
Interview: Tony and the panel discuss Alex's young appearance and elf-like features. They praise his opening but note he only did half his allotted time. Dom offers genuine compliments about his entrance and delivery.
- Girls want low-drama relationships but he wants high drama, Phantom mask
- Alex completes his set in only 35 seconds instead of the full 60-second allowance
- Panel members praise his opening entrance as the strongest part of his performance
Set: Patrick delivers an extremely dark and bleak one-liner set, spoken in an exaggerated Dan Mintz-like voice, covering topics like his friend killing a hooker, his mother dying in childbirth, his father abandoning him at an orphanage, and attempting anal sex with his girlfriend's brother.
Interview: Tony critiques Patrick's affected voice and suggests he could maintain dark comedy while sounding more natural. Patrick reveals depression struggles, eventually reveals he plays guitar, and the panel encourages him to perform.
- Friend killed hooker on his birthday = mother died giving birth
- Dad told him one man's trash is another's treasure while dropping him at orphanage
- Surprised girlfriend during sleep by attempting anal with her brother
- Patrick unexpectedly reveals he can play guitar and performs an impromptu musical jam with Jeremiah Watkins
- Patrick and Jeremiah collaborate on an original song titled 'Patrick' about his struggles
- Tony praises Patrick's guitar abilities and emotional turnaround after initially poor set reception
Set: Andy discusses his breakdown in LA, a helpful crazy man, recovery from seven-year heroin addiction, and his work at a treatment center in Malibu. He uses self-deprecating humor about his appearance.
Interview: Tony praises Andy as top-five funniest performers on the show. Extended discussion of Andy's heroin addiction, recovery, stupid things he did to score drugs (including stealing his niece's tricycle), and his current work in recovery.
- Car broke down, crazy man suggested jump with bike and ramp
- Looks like bully from 90s Disney movie, mom said Hitler youth locked in Golden Corral
- Extended discussion of Andy stealing his niece's tricycle to escape drug dealers
- Andy reveals he tricked a girl into sex, then gave her peanut in balloon instead of heroin as payoff
- Tony praises Andy as genuinely one of the top five funniest bucket performers ever
Set: Travis discusses his six years as an Army medic, a recent study about orgasms preventing prostate cancer, and jokes about his wife not having a prostate and his grandfather's death.
Interview: Extended discussion of Travis's military service including duty in Afghanistan, combat medic experiences treating Taliban soldiers, infrared cameras catching soldiers having sex, drug use on base, and various exploits during deployment.
- Study says orgasm daily prevents prostate cancer; glad wife doesn't have one
- Pat Reagan booing Travis's military service introduction, then apologizing
- Extended discussion of infrared cameras catching soldiers having sex on base
- Travis reveals he saved lives of Taliban soldiers as a medic
Set: The Virzi Triplets perform material about their abusive father hitting them, their mother being passive, watching porn at 13 and being punished, Catholic upbringing with physical beatings, and sexual situations including circle jerks.
Interview: Tony and panel discuss the triplets' similar appearance and joke about their act. One triplet has a cold sore covered with a band aid. Discussion of one triplet's date with a girl with a troubled family background.
- Dad hit them as kids, mom didn't because she was big pussy
- Dad did sign of cross before hitting them with belt
- Dad caught him watching porn at 13, told him put belt around neck for harder cum
- One triplet's cold sore covered with band aid for second week in a row
- One triplet reveals he stole a girl from another triplet's date
- Girl on date disclosed her father had Hep C, cancer, spent life in prison
Set: Ali discusses having two attractive single sisters and showing photos to potential dates, framing shots to highlight sister's body parts. She discusses dating app experiences and a first date attempt with anal sex that went poorly.
Interview: Tony suggests Ali keep jokes more personal. Discussion of her first anal sex experience at 17, using leg lotion as lube which burned, her boyfriend Blake, and traveling to Hawaii. Ali announces she's moving to New York City January 14th.
- Shows pictures of sisters to dates, frames shots to highlight butt stuff interest
- Hard as woman and comedian to hook up because guys ask if you'll talk about it
- Ali discusses first anal sex experience at 17 using Cocoa Butter lotion which burned
- Extended discussion of anal sex preparation and technique between Ali and panel
- Ali announces she's moving to New York City January 14th, this is second-to-last appearance
Set: Nicole discusses being dumped in a hotel lobby while crying, tourists asking her to take their photo, and making a dark joke that she hates Koreans (then corrects herself).
Interview: Tony and panel confirm the incident happened. Discussion of the breakup six to seven months ago, her continued friendship with ex-boyfriend, and whether the experience was worth the comedic material.
- Dumped in hotel lobby, tourists asked them to take their picture
- Selfie invented so you don't ask strangers to photo at funerals
- Nicole makes controversial joke saying she hates Koreans, then says she doesn't know their race
- Panel praises Nicole as consistently one of the funniest bucket performers
Set: Afrodyete discusses how her large ass prevents her from fitting in office chairs, types with her breasts, discusses difficulty finding employment as a Black woman, and describes taking fictional 'Dolby Black' pills that bleached her skin for a job interview.
Interview: Extended discussion of Afrodyete's racial experiences, dating preferences, and physical attributes. Panel engages with her ranking men she'd 'fuck,' controversial banter about race and sexuality.
- Can't get work because ass too big, office needs two chairs per cheek
- Took Dolby Black pills to turn white for job interview, afro popped out
- Afrodyete sexually ranks all male performers and panel members on stage
- Tony imitates Afrodyete's voice and sexual commentary in exaggerated manner
- Afrodyete mentions her band Jungle Fire performed at Grand Park New Year's Eve with thousands of people
- Extended discussion of Afrodyete's New Year's resolutions and racial anger