Kill Tony #405 — David Lucas, William Montgomery, Caroline Smith
Guests: David Lucas · William Montgomery · Caroline Smith
Lineup
Set: Jay discusses his manboobs, dating women with small breasts, anal play with his girlfriend, and discovering fetishes as a child through an illegal cable box and a model rocket.
Interview: Tony learns Jay is a first-time comedian and product designer in telecom software. Jay reveals his father was absent and he won his first MMA fight via first-round knockout.
- I date girls with small boobs because I like to be dominant
- My friends say I'm probably into men; I like to think I'm into women of long fingers
- Went to bathroom and stuck a model rocket up my butt to experiment with fetishes
- David Lucas jokes that Jay looks like 'Matt Damon with serious brain trauma'
Set: David performs a new minute about dating, sex positions, and his physical appearance. He talks about not having sex with skinny girls and his ability to do only two push-ups.
Interview: Panel roasts David about weight gain. David jokes back about the band. He joins the panel for the rest of the show.
- Girls thinking doggy style but I have bad knees and can't do that position
- Don't have sex with skinny girls—it's like an attempted homicide charge
- Can't do missionary because I can only do two push-ups
- William Montgomery joins panel and immediately starts roasting David
John Gab
Set: John describes his appearance as looking like a gay garden gnome or Game of Thrones character at a music festival. He does a comedic character bit as 'Jon of House Coachella.'
Interview: John reveals this is his first time ever doing stand-up comedy (started at Kill Tony in June). He works with special needs adults and does some drug use.
- I look like the gayest garden gnome you've ever laid eyes on
- Guy told me I look like a Game of Thrones character at a music festival
- Tony reveals John's first-ever comedy appearance was at Kill Tony, and he's been doing shows regularly since
Keanan
Set: Keanan discusses China's one-child policy, overpopulation, and young parents. He makes political jokes about Trump and climate change while discussing children.
Interview: Keanan is a first-time comedian and graphic designer from Atlanta. He's a rapper and went to St. Barts with friends. Panel questions his material and crowd reception.
- China got the one-child policy right; one kid free TV
- Jessica and Danny in Noe Valley talking about kids while planet melts
- Crowd boos heavily during set; Tony stops Keanan to remind audience not to interrupt
- Panel calls Keanan 'unlikable' during interview; he admits people rarely call him their friend
Set: William performs a new minute with pandering callbacks to Sacramento and San Francisco locations. He mentions his wedding date coinciding with Full House's premiere and his uncle Ralph on the Challenger shuttle.
Interview: Tony discusses William's technique of connecting with audiences through location-specific references and winking. William joins panel and continues with roasts and commentary.
- September 22, 1987 I got married; also when Full House aired—give it up for Olsen twins
- Uncle Ralph Martinez blew up on Challenger shuttle—I've never stolen that much food
- Tony notes William has perfected the technique of naming local references to manipulate crowd reactions
- William does his signature wink move multiple times during interview
Elisabeth Stricklin
Set: Caroline is a 17-year-old high school student who eats lunch in special ed classrooms. She jokes about finding a student with Down syndrome going through her bags and masturbating on her school supplies.
Interview: Caroline is the youngest-ever golden ticket winner (originally 16, now 17). She's been performing at bar shows and mics in Raleigh. Plans to be a TV writer.
- Eats lunch in special ed classrooms because none of them can talk and annoy me
- Student with Down syndrome was looking for his missing chromosome but jerked off on my supplies
- Tony reveals Caroline is the youngest-ever golden ticket winner in show history
- Caroline crushes her second appearance; described as 'striking gold' with real comedy
- Caroline joins panel for remainder of show and participates in audience interactions
Gordon X
Set: Gordon attempts to discuss a solution to Middle East tensions but becomes very nervous and poorly articulates his ideas. He struggles throughout and doesn't land jokes.
Interview: Gordon is from Oakland, works at a liquor store, and rides an electric scooter. He admits to needing to use the bathroom and struggles emotionally during the interview.
- Gordon bombs significantly; described by Tony as 'one of the worst sets I've ever seen'
- Gordon reveals his hobby is using a sex toy device called Real Touch
- Tony sets up narrative for Gordon to potentially return next year and redeem himself
Set: Stick Boy discusses his soft penis and compares himself to a bulldog in spaghetti. He talks about multitasking by brushing teeth while defecating and attempting oral sex during menstruation.
Interview: Stick Boy is a first-time comedian from Denver who recently moved to Portland. He's a project manager in a long-distance relationship with someone in Minneapolis.
- Girlfriend said my soft dick is like a bulldog in spaghetti
- Brush my teeth while taking a shit to save time
- Eating girl out with big bush tried to floss teeth
- Panel initiates impromptu pubic hair competition with Stick Boy and Bartholomew Jenkins (band member)
- Stick Boy and Bartholomew display their pubic hair on stage for comparison/judging
- Caroline Smith (17 years old) is on stage during pubic hair segment; Tony expresses concern
Set: Arturo starts discussing pooping himself at a thrift store with his mom but doesn't finish the joke due to time constraints.
Interview: Arturo is a first-time comedian from San Francisco who works at a landfill. He has a girlfriend and enjoys finding random items in trash.
- Nearly pooped myself at thrift store with my mom
- Panel coaches Arturo to use catchphrase 'I'm Mexican man' after nearly every statement
- Arturo mentions finding a relic and bear paw while working at landfill
Sparks
Set: Sparks discusses growing up in San Francisco's Excelsior District, neighborhood changes from gang violence to yoga instructors calling cops, and being a Navy veteran from a Mexican-white family.
Interview: Sparks is a first-time comedian and Navy veteran who grew up in Outer Mission/Excelsior. He references gang culture and acknowledges Caroline Smith as Crips-affiliated.
- Used to get jumped wearing wrong colors in Mission; now just criticized for fashionable colors
- Mom throwing up E for Excelsior gang sign back in the day
- Sparks sprints to stage and is out of breath, exemplifying Tony's warning about not running
- Panel continues roasting Elisabeth Strickling during Sparks' set/interview
Set: Ryan discusses inability to distinguish between being high and angry, mentioning red watery eyes. Makes joke about being broke and using AAA for gas.
Interview: Ryan is an electrician with recently adopted dog and 11 fingers. Very brief interview with minimal discussion.
- Can't tell if I'm high or angry; both make my eyes red and watery
- So broke I call AAA for gas even though that's not what they do
Todd Royce
Set: Todd performs material about his mother's five marriages, his wife's criticism, arguments in his 12-year marriage, and the absurdity of unsolicited dick pics, ending with a story about sending himself photos.
Interview: Todd is a 12-year married golden ticket winner who recently lost 22 pounds on keto. He's a professional wrestler/entertainer and works in countertops. Wife works at architectural hardware store.
- Mom married 5 times; I've had more dads than girlfriends
- 12-year marriage means more arguments than sex, wife criticizes everything
- Only person I've sent a dick pic to is myself just to check in
- Todd Royce attempts to body slam Jeremiah Watkins but band retaliates and slams Todd instead
- Tony describes Todd as 'the white David Lucas' and mentions his impressive keto weight loss
- Todd is revealed to be a golden ticket winner who cashed in at Comedy Store and chokeslammed Joel through a table