Kill Tony #725 — Matt Rife, Adam Ray
Guests: Matt Rife · Adam Ray
Lineup
Set: Cassandra's first-ever standup set about asking her cousin for bedroom advice, leading to a joke about introducing racial slurs into intimate situations with her white husband.
Interview: Tony learns this is her first time ever on stage, that she owns a food truck called Slothful Waffle with her white husband, and they met in Palm Springs. Discussion of her mixed-race identity (half Black, half Ecuadorian) and family background.
- Cousin advised introducing racial slurs in bedroom; husband countered with 'honky' (1920s prostitution reference)
- First bucket pull of the night, first time ever performing standup in an arena
BC
Set: BC's set about making fun of overweight people, their shoes, and a fat friend who kicked out a bottle of Hershey's syrup from his car.
Interview: Tony roasts BC's appearance extensively. BC has been doing standup for 3 years in Atlanta and LA. He's a set builder for commercials including Home Depot. Claims to be 5 years clean from crack cocaine.
- Fat people's shoes look like flat tires; New Balances called 'Off Balances'
- Fat friend kicking Hershey's syrup out of car while making chocolate milk
- Tony roasts BC's appearance with multiple Down Syndrome jokes and comparisons
- BC claims to have fixed Tony's brakes previously
Set: Jonathan's first standup set about looking like 'Ari Maddie MGK' and an encounter with an old man who thought he was gay, plus commentary on code-switching in gay groups.
Interview: First-time standup performer. Works in HVAC. From Augusta, Georgia. Has tattoos including one that says 'you crack me up' and a problematic matching tattoo situation with an ex.
- Looks like 'Ari Maddie MGK for his green card'; old man thought he was gay
- Code-switching uncool when around gay people
- First-time performer, Tony critiques his stage presence and eye contact during interview
- Has tattoo of ex's name with arrow pointing to his genitals
Set: Aaron is going blind in his left eye (wearing an eye patch), was hospitalized without insurance, ate a Tide pod, and makes jokes comparing pet insurance coverage to human healthcare, joking about becoming a dog for better coverage.
Interview: Aaron explains he's visited five doctors in a week while uninsured and quit his job but makes enough as a comedian to pay cash. Tony and panel make eye patch/pirate jokes throughout.
- Pet insurance covers 90% for $80/month; humans should identify as dogs
- Doctors can't diagnose eye condition; admits to eating Tide pod
- Golden Ticket winner wearing eye patch, physical comedy and energy-based humor
- Panel extensively riffs on eye patch/pirate theme and Canadian identity
Set: First-time standup about racial confusion. Jeremiah has been with a Black woman but Black friends say it doesn't count due to a 'threshold of blackness.' He contrasts this with Puerto Ricans who say the N-word without issue.
Interview: First-time performer. Got a 7-month government severance after being fired, worked in systems maintenance from home. Now a Tony-approved new comedian.
- Black friends say dating Black woman doesn't count; there's a racial threshold
- Puerto Ricans say N-word without criticism but higher bar for others
- First-time performer, Tony quickly moves through interview
Set: Under-one-year comic from Nashville (originally Calgary, Canada). Sets up joke about Metallica being Christian rock due to 'Enter Sandman,' his uncle's murder-suicide. Also jokes about not wanting to hang around gay dudes due to expenses.
Interview: From Calgary, Alberta. Works in construction (renovations/new builds). Does open mics at least weekly at The Lab in Nashville. Married with three kids (8, 5, 3—two boys, one girl). Previously worked as a cremator.
- 'Enter Sandman' is Christian prayer; uncle's murder-suicide wasn't fairy tale ending
- Gay dudes expensive (hair gel, coffee mugs); would perform oral sex for Lululemon shorts
- Discusses disturbing job as cremator; found cremated items, handled dead bodies
Set: Nashville native and Kill Tony regular in wheelchair. Jokes about disabled hierarchy, bathroom independence equals street cred. Comments on Southern saying 'God gives toughest battles to strongest warriors'—from her perspective, audience looks weak.
Interview: Engaged to Matt Taylor. Just started podcast 'Ramping Up.' Shares shocking story about ex-boyfriend who peed in mason jars instead of using bathroom, one of which spilled on her head while on bed. DraftKings bet reference about catching bouquet.
- Disabled hierarchy: harder to use bathroom = more street cred; scooters get priority
- Southern saying 'God gives toughest battles to strongest warriors'—y'all look weak
- Kill Tony regular in home venue, strong crowd support
- Reveals ex-boyfriend peed in mason jars; one spilled on her head
Set: Kill Tony debut. Grew up one of five white kids in all-Black school, looked like Waldo in yearbook. Girl told him he looked like Kevin Bacon from Footloose. Did 23andMe test, joked that results said he's transgender (got fat breasts). Actually Irish and Native American with DUIs in family.
Interview: Civil engineer overseeing construction sites. Likes hiking at Radner Lake near Nashville. Former Marine water engineer with one bad knee. Wears hats that were suggested by comedians backstage. Described as 'misshapen' with short legs, big body, tiny head.
- Only white kid in all-Black school; appeared in yearbook like Where's Waldo
- Girl said he looked like Kevin Bacon; 23andMe said he's transgender (got fat)
- Tony roasts Dustin's body proportions extensively throughout interview
Set: Kam does 50+ seconds about a female friend in hospital beaten by boyfriend (black eye, broken ribs, fractured leg). He asks 'What did we learn?' She replies 'Don't date your favorite comedian.' Ends with: 'That's all I got.'
Interview: Extensive riffing on Kam's outfit: sweatpants with cowboy boots. Tony and panel make country music references and call him various country artist names ('Dolly Parton and the Black guy,' etc.). Kam gets progressively annoyed about being roasted.
- Friend tells comedians they caused her boyfriend to beat her
- Extended panel riffing on Kam's cowboy outfit, creating country singer name mashups
- Kam frustrated by roasting, claims the hat cost $400
- Kam throws hat into crowd, asks to sign it for audience member
Robbie
Set: First-time performer. Sets up joke about double standard: coworker announcing pregnant woman at 6cm dilation is acceptable, but his prior comments about woman's tightness got him sent to HR. Also jokes about his three disappointing kids: atheist lesbian daughter, daughter dating Mexican man, and ungrateful son.
Interview: First-time standup, only about a minute of practice. Chose Nashville over Austin open mic because it's closer. Works custom cabinetry and cooks at restaurant. Formerly in band that got successful after he left (he was 'the anchor'.
- Coworker announces labor dilation; his previous comments about woman got HR complaint
- Three kids: atheist lesbian daughter, daughter dating Mexican, ungrateful son
- First-time performer chose arena over open mic for debut
Set: Estonian comedian (pursuing US citizenship). Nashville experience: at house party, talking to girl, guy pulled out guitar ('there goes my pussy'). Doesn't trust guys good at things. Estonia: accordion, not guitar. Accordion sounds like communism: 'There is never enough bread.' Accordion makes you suicidal.
Interview: Matt Rife flirts extensively with Ari. Tony discusses Nashville residency possibilities, compares Austin and Nashville vibes. Discusses tornado chair incident at rooftop bar. Redband was left at Kid Rock's bar overnight.
- Guy with guitar at party killed romantic moment; accordion sounds like communism
- Accordion sounds like 'There is never enough bread.' Accordion kills you, doesn't make you wet.
- Matt Rife extensively flirts with Ari on stage
- Hitler reference during interview
- Redband accordion button used; story of Redband left at Kid Rock's bar
Set: Canadian comedian (set bombed). Defends himself for being late—was getting 'busy' with Haley backstage. Nashville women: jokes about largest women's prison in US, 'easy ass after 10pm.' Rushed ending thanking crowd. Left long pauses for jokes that didn't land.
Interview: Couple years of standup. Tony critiques his Canadian excuses and national anthem booing. Two broken vertebrae post-high school from wrestling. Works for large American company in Canada. Crowd consistently boos him.
- Largest women's prison in US; easy dating after 10pm
- Crowd heavily boos Canadian performer; Tony critiques Canadian national anthem booing
Set: Golden Ticket regular. Short set: French horn is sexy instrument (fist in it). Ted Bundy volunteered at suicide hotline but nobody talks about lives he saved. Ends abruptly: 'I'll end it there.'
Interview: Took nap during tornado warning, didn't evacuate. Possibly attended or missed drag brunch. Mixed up with Aaron Balile (both in wheelchairs/mobility issues). Tony mentions Martin has record for most Golden Ticket appearances. Invites him to party in Memphis.
- French horn sexy because you stick fist in it
- Ted Bundy volunteered at suicide hotline; nobody talks about lives he saved
- Golden Ticket winner, record holder for most appearances of any Golden Ticket winner
- Confused with Aaron Balile due to similar mobility situations; names mixed up in lineup
Calep Lee
Set: Four-year comic from Dayton, Ohio. Girl on social media saying she'll kill herself if she doesn't get 25 likes. He messages encouragement; she leaves him on read. Reveals he sells weed to her sister, tells her to kill herself. Crowd boos heavily throughout.
Interview: 29 years old. Works Door Dash and sells weed. Mother deceased (cremated). Tries to plug open mic in Dayton with friend Jeff Allen. Tony shuts him down, says Dayton doesn't matter. Called 'least liked American of the night.'
- Girl threatens suicide for social media likes; he tells her to kill herself
- Crowd boos relentlessly throughout set and interview
- Mother's death mentioned casually; says she's in an 'urn'/'earn'
Evan Burke
Set: 15-year comedy veteran (since ~2009). At 17, was in middle back seat of car without seatbelt during accident. The two guys next to him died, but he survived. Now those guys are dead from opioids. Quick callback: 'Everyone survived the accident, but those guys are dead.'
Interview: Started in Charleston, SC, then Atlanta, New York, LA. Did show with Tony at LA Ice House on Valentine's Day 2020 (made woman cry calling her lady of the night). Works remotely for research company AlphaSense. Self-produced comedy special using day job money.
- Car accident: middle seat guy survived; two next to him died, now from opioids
- 15-year veteran pulled from audience during impromptu opportunity; strong interview with Tony
- Tony recalls Evan making woman cry in LA Ice House 2020 show
Set: 11-year-old comic. Mother named him to be alcoholic by 21. After school goes to YMCA (calls it 'hell'). Friends there barely older than kids, have pimples. Friend Jackson is 5'4''. Kids forced to wash hands daily like they have disease, eat expired food.
Interview: 11 years old from Lexington, Kentucky. Writes jokes himself; runs them by parents (both present). Watches show with dad, occasionally. Doesn't curse much (says 'poop' when asked for favorite curse word). Awarded Golden Ticket to Madison Square Garden.
- Mother named him to be alcoholic by 21; forced to go to YMCA 'hell'
- Kids at YMCA staff barely older, have pimples; forced to wash hands daily
- First 11-year-old to perform on Kill Tony; awarded Golden Ticket to MSG
- When asked for favorite curse word, says 'poop' to crowd disapproval